1.Skinfold Thickness..
Determination of Body fat by means of
calipers dates from early 50 S.
Calipers are inexpensive and portable.
Measurements are easy to perform, and are quite acceptable to patients.(37-38- 128-
141-142-191- 234- 327- 328-329- 373- 435-489) (Figure 3 a).
The technique does not a require a very
trained Personnel, and can be performed on a daily basis, "pinching" the
subcutaneous fat layer located beneath the skin by means of a special
caliper.
Several studies were reported assessing the
relationship between body fat and skinfolds. For example, data from the Honolulu Heart
Program concluded that the risk of developing coronary disease is greater for those with a
higher subscapular skinfold thickness at any level of BMI Body Mass Index.) (134).
Some studies report an acceptable
correlation between skinfold thickness and body fat. These reports concluded that it is
possible to estimate body fatness from the use of skinfold calipers.(191).
There are, however, several problems that
should be considered when using skinfold. One of them is the fact that interobserver
variations are considerable. On the other hand, a report from Bray and coworkers has found
greater interobserver differences among skinfold measurements taken on obese subjects than
on lean subjects.(191)
The other problem is that not always body
fat maintains a good correlation with skinfolds.
Despite all its limitations, skinfold may
yield valuable data concerning trends in fatness over time within
individuals.
2.Circumferences.
Circumference measurement is a method that
can be compared to Skinfold and Densitomethry, as far as acceptability by patients, ease,
and accuracy is concerned.(38-39-72).
It seems that the method is less subjected
to interobserver errors than skinfold thickness, even in obese patients.
The most valuable use of circumference
measurements might be in the field of estimating of body fat distribution.(195)
It is therefore possible to characterize
obese patients based on the ratio of circumferences of the abdomen (or waist) to the
gluteal region. the so-called Waist-to-Hip Ratio (WHR) Any cipher close to 1 forewarns a
greater risk for death, strike and ischemic heart disease. Conversely, a ratio below to,
or close to 0.8 decreases the risks for such diseases.( 152-266-268-518-520)
Therefore individuals with abdominal
obesity are at a greater risk than those displaying gluteofemoral obesity.
3.Bioelectrical
Impedance.
Bioelectrical impedance works on the
principle that resistance is inversely proportional to total body water, when an
electrical current (75 MHz) is applied through several electrodes placed on body
extremities.
Impedance has been shown to correlate very
well with total body water assessed by more sophisticated methods.(190-192-282-305-344-).
The device to estimate body fat by
Densitomethry is light-weighted, and can be performed on a daily basis (Figure 3 b). They
are portable, the technique is easily reproducible and easy to use. The method is quite
acceptable to patients (4)
Electrodes are placed distal to right
extremities (Arm and lower limbs) and homolateral(right half of the body.(129-131).
When regression equations are used
including weight, height, age, and sex, correlation of Densitomethry with lean body mass
as determined by underwater weighing are near 0.96 It can, therefore, be used outside the
Laboratory settings to assess with great accuracy body composition.(116-283-452-506)
C. Obesity by clinical complications.
Obesity could also be defined as a sort of
interrelationship between body weight and complications arisen from body weight. This
procedure seems more coherent as far as the urgency for a medical treatment has to be
considered.
Thus, an individual showing a BMI of 23%,
but hypertense should be treated more imperatively than a 30% BMI with no clinical
complications in his History. Individuals displaying the android type of body fat
distribution could be included in this category.
Several studies suggest a strong
association between Body fat distribution body weight, and high blood pressure, the same
correlation observed in hypertensive subjects showing and abdominal type of body fat
distribution.
It has been observed that even near-normal
weight individuals may exhibit these complications despite being slightly
overweight.
D.Obesity by body fat distribution.
It was probably Morgagni who described for
the first time the android type of obesity in a woman, who had "virile aspectu et
valde obesa." . Later Marañon in Spain and Pende in Italy described respectively
hyperstenic and hyposthenic obesities.(90).
But was Jean Vague who unquestionably
suggested for the first time that body fat distribution and clinical complications,
obesity can be split in two categories: Android and Gynoid or the so-called "Pear and
Apple-shaped obesities," depending on the anatomical site where fat is more
preponderant.(123-124-125-257- 426- 472- 473-474- 475- 476- 477- 478- 480- 481- 482)(
Figure 4) .
In the android type of obesity, fat is
mainly located in the truncal area (upper body , nape of the neck, shoulder,
supraumbilical abdomen.) When it appears in the female population , they show signs of
virilization (hirsutism, more developed musculature) . (124-125-167-277-502) (Figures 4 a
and b).
Gynoid obesity, by contrary, displays a
female aspect in the subjects (Rounded Hips, more fat located in the upper part of the
body, buttocks, thighs, subumbilical abdomen). Muscular mass is less developed. Women
displaying the android type of obesity are subjected to similar complications than males
with android overweight
Diabetic and arterial risks for the cases
of android obesity are multiplied by a factor or 6 or 20 when compared to gynoid
obesity.(250-285- 306-309-336-346-359-371-416-417-486)
These study matches very well with those
showing that blood pressure, gout, several types of cancer were closely associated to a
central distribution of fat.
Compared to males, female populations
showing the "gynoid" type of obesity exhibit more body fat as estimated by
Densitomethry , but are in turn less prone to metabolic complications.(503)
E. Obesity by adipose cells morphology
Excess fat can be stored in an increased
number of adipocytes, or in enlarged fat cells. These two different conditions have been
formerly described as hyperplasthic obesity respectively.(49-50-51-52-53-54-84-198-218-223-335-403-404-432)
It was found that enlarged fat cells were
highly associated to elevated plasma insulin levels, type 11 diabetes mellitus, endogenous
hypertriglyceridaemia and essential hypertension. (49-50-51-279-280).
Hypertrophic obesity was therefore related
to metabolic aberrations,. whereas hyperplastic obesity was found in early-onset obesity
with enlarged visceral organ. It shows a good correlation between fat cell number and
total body cell mass.(48-81)
Subcutaneous fat layer of young women in
the gluteal and femoral regions is mainly due to an increase in cell number
(hyperplastic), whereas the abdominal type of obesity correspond to the Hypertrophic
type.(49-50-51-52)
In women displaying the gynoid type of
obesity, fat cell size is smaller in the abdominal region when compared to the femoral
area, whereas there is no such difference in men throughout the life span. The female
pattern of body fat distribution is maintained with increasing obesity and age
These different fat depots are subjected,
as we will see later, to different metabolic regulations. where sex hormones play an
important role in body fat distribution.
CONCLUSIONS.
A considerable body of References estimate
that normal body fat percentages are 15-20 per cent in men and 20 to 25 per cent in women.
any cipher exceeding these standards is considered obesity. Therefore, and based on Body
fat, we could define Obesity as a body fat content of above 30 per cent for women and 25
per cent for men.
Circumference is apt to determine the WHR
(Waist to Hip Ratio). A cipher close to (or above) 1 is closely related to clinical
complications. Densitomethry is a valuable and accurate diagnostic tool, apt to be used in
the daily practice.
Regardless the method selected to classify
Obesity, all of them concur to a point: Excessive body fat (whether the subject is obese
or not according to Height/Weight Tables) is the common denominator to all of
them.
We could therefore define Obesity as an
accumulation of excessive body fat, well over the daily metabolic requirements of
facultative energy storage in the form of tryglicerides.
Together with environmental factors
heredity plays a determinant role in the genesis of this surplus accumulation of body
fat.
|